605 - Shultz/Creighton Real Estate | 605 - Shultz/Creighton Historical Properties for Sale

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 205898 MLS

Situated in the heart of Flagstaff, this charming 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers 743 square feet of efficient, character-filled living space at 904 W Clay Ave. Perfectly positioned within Historic Downtown Flagstaff and Northern Arizona University, the property delivers unbeatable convenience to local dining, shops, and community events. Built in 1936 on a manageable 0.10-acre lot, this home blends classic historic charm with incredible potential for primary residents, university affiliates, or investors looking for a prime location. Enjoy easy access to urban amenities while being just minutes away from outdoor trails and mountain recreation. A rare opportunity to own a standalone home in one of Flagstaff's most desirable and accessible neighborhoods!

904 W Clay Avenue, Flagstaff

$1,200,000

205869 MLS

Experience the best of Historic Downtown Flagstaff with this charming multi-unit property, ideally located within easy walking distance of restaurants, shopping, galleries, coffee shops, and all that vibrant downtown has to offer. The original home, built in 1900, offers timeless character with 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, beautiful hardwood floors, and a thoughtfully updated kitchen featuring a dishwasher and gas range. Historic details combined with modern conveniences create a warm and inviting living space. The second unit provides excellent flexibility with 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, air conditioning, and an oversized 2-car garage. Additional alley parking adds even more convenience--an exceptional feature in downtown Flagstaff. Whether you're looking for a primary residence with additional income potential, a multi-generational setup, or an investment property in one of Flagstaff's most desirable locations, this property offers a rare combination of historic charm, functionality, parking, and walkable downtown shops, entertainment, and historic attractions.

210 N Elden Street, Flagstaff

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 205783 MLS

Amazing opportunity to own a home in the heart of downtown Flagstaff! This property is an investor's dream, currently operating as a successful short-term rental with the opportunity to transfer to the new owner. Plans have already been submitted to the City for an additional 1,706 sq. ft. home featuring 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. The approved design offers flexibility to create either a 3 bed/3 bath home or separate 1 bed/1 bath and 2 bed/2 bath units--providing the potential for 1-2 additional rentals on the property. Don't miss this rare opportunity to maximize rental income and ROI in downtown Flagstaff!

817 N Beaver Street, Flagstaff

$1,490,000

205589 MLS

Discover a rare investment opportunity in the heart of Historic Downtown Flagstaff. The iconic circa 1906 Lindemann House occupies a high-profile corner lot and includes an expansive paved parking lot--an exceptional amenity in downtown Flagstaff. Rich in history, character, and income potential, this unique property offers flexibility for investors, business owners, or those seeking a mixed-use opportunity. The property features five residential units, including two 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartments, two 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartments, and one studio apartment. Currently operated with a combination of short- and long-term rentals, all units are transitioning to long-term rentals, providing stable income with additional upside potential. SELLER FINANCING is available to qualified Buyers, and the Seller prefers a Seller Financed sale. Flagstaff's desirable Community Commercial (CC) zoning allows for a wide variety of commercial and residential uses. Over the years, the property has successfully housed a retail running store, hair salon, attorney's office, engineering office, and residential apartments, creating exceptional flexibility for future ownership. The oversized paved parking lot provides abundant off-street parking--an increasingly valuable asset in Historic Downtown Flagstaff. Whether you continue its successful income-producing history, establish your own business, redevelop the site within zoning allowances, or create a unique live/work environment, the possibilities are extensive. This is a one-of-a-kind historic downtown property offering character, strong income potential, outstanding visibility, abundant parking, flexible zoning, and exceptional long-term investment value. Owner/Agent.

309 N Humphreys Street, Flagstaff

$1,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 205571 MLS

Just a few blocks from Heritage Square, local shops, and some of the city's most beloved restaurants, this vibrant 1915 bungalow perfectly captures the charm and character of historic downtown Flagstaff living. Step inside and you'll be captivated by original hardwood floors, an inviting fireplace, and large picturesque windows that fill the interior with natural light. Reclaimed wood from Flagstaff's historic sawmill was incorporated throughout, adding warmth, authenticity, and a true local story to every room. The main home features 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a formal dining room, a cozy den, and several charming nooks. Downstairs, a separate apartment-style living space with its own private entrance offers incredible flexibility--ideal for guests, multigenerational living, a home or potential Airbnb income. Outdoors, the beautifully landscaped backyard--featured twice in Northern Arizona's Mountain Living Magazine--serves as a private retreat. Gorgeous flagstone terraces, mature landscaping, and colorful flowers create the perfect setting for morning coffee, unwinding in the fresh mountain air, or entertaining friends and family. Rare opportunities like this don't come around often. Whether you're looking for an exceptional primary residence, an investment opportunity, or both, this one-of-a-kind property offers an unbeatable downtown location with timeless character and endless potential.

2 N Hillside Street, Flagstaff

$1,490,000

205569 MLS

Discover a rare investment opportunity in the heart of Historic Downtown Flagstaff. The iconic circa 1906 Lindemann House occupies a high-profile corner lot and includes an expansive paved parking lot--an exceptional amenity in downtown Flagstaff. Rich in history, character, and income potential, this unique property offers flexibility for investors, business owners, or those seeking a mixed-use opportunity. The property features five residential units, including two 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartments, two 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartments, and one studio apartment. Currently operated with a combination of short- and long-term rentals, all units are transitioning to long-term rentals, providing stable income with additional upside potential. SELLER FINANCING is available to qualified Buyers, and the Seller prefers a Seller Financed sale. Flagstaff's desirable Community Commercial (CC) zoning allows for a wide variety of commercial and residential uses. Over the years, the property has successfully housed a retail running store, hair salon, attorney's office, engineering office, and residential apartments, creating exceptional flexibility for future ownership. The oversized paved parking lot provides abundant off-street parking--an increasingly valuable asset in Historic Downtown Flagstaff. Whether you continue its successful income-producing history, establish your own business, redevelop the site within zoning allowances, or create a unique live/work environment, the possibilities are extensive. This is a one-of-a-kind historic downtown property offering character, strong income potential, outstanding visibility, abundant parking, flexible zoning, and exceptional long-term investment value. Owner/Agent.

309 N Humphreys Street, Flagstaff

$595,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 205482 MLS

The house everyone knows--now updated! This popular Southside 5-bedroom, 2-bath investment property offers a prime location between downtown Flagstaff and the NAU campus, making it a consistently desirable rental in a market with limited inventory of its kind. Thoughtful improvements made by the current owner include remodeled bathrooms and kitchen, new downstairs flooring, fresh interior paint, an electric water heater, furnace replacement, added A/C, and updated kitchen appliances, cabinets, and countertops. With its strategic location, multiple surface parking spaces, strong rental appeal, and substantial recent upgrades, this property is an ideal opportunity for investors seeking reliable rental demand and compelling long-term returns.

324 S San Francisco Street, Flagstaff

$499,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 205271 MLS

This rare 7,000 sq ft lot is in an unbeatable location, just blocks from NAU. It already has rental potential or buyer could add to that by redeveloping and adding an accessory dwelling unit (ADU), a rear alley facing second house, or pursuing full multi-unit redevelopment. New zoning rules allow for four units using the City of Flagstaff's new faster approval process. The parcel also conveys with a binding waiver of enforcement of the city's onerous High Occupancy Housing (HOH) Ordinance. Similar neighboring parcels are being fully redeveloped into lucrative high-density student housing duplexes and complexes. The property has been a rental for the past 5 years at 2,500/month. Rent the property while you plan the next steps for your investment! Owner is a licensed agent.

404 S Verde Street, Flagstaff

$285,000

1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7052720 MLS

Opportunity is knocking! This fixer-upper in the heart beautiful Flagstaff is ready for an investor or lots of TLC to make it your own. Located on a large, fenced corner lot, this one story home is just moments from Downtown Flagstaff and NAU and there is no HOA! There is a sun room not included in square footage and a garage! Whether you refresh the existing home, add an ADU or start anew, there is so much potential here! This is an as-is, cash only sale. Price reflects condition.

530 W Tombstone Avenue, Flagstaff

$285,000

1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 205247 MLS

Opportunity is knocking! This fixer-upper in the heart beautiful Flagstaff is ready for an investor or lots of TLC to make it your own. Located on a large, fenced corner lot, this one story home is just moments from Downtown Flagstaff and NAU and there is no HOA! There is a sun room not included in square footage and a garage! Whether you refresh the existing home, add an ADU or start anew, there is so much potential here! This is an as-is, cash only sale. Price reflects condition.

530 W Tombstone Avenue, Flagstaff

$725,000

205228 MLS

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY! Here is your chance to own a duplex in downtown Flagstaff. Located close to the hospital.This property is being sold in as is condition and needs a lot of work.

906 N Beaver Street Unit 1-2, Flagstaff

$450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 205011 MLS

WELCOME HOME! 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offering 1,141 sq. ft. of comfortable living space. The remodeled kitchen and bathroom, along with refreshed bedrooms and living areas, make this home truly move-in ready. Situated on a large lot, the spacious backyard provides plenty of room for entertaining, outdoor activities, future expansion, or additional improvements. A storage shed offers extra space for tools, equipment, and storage needs. Community Commercial zoning adds flexibility and future potential. To help ensure a smooth transaction, the property has been inspected and prepared for an easy buyer inspection. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, schools, and local amenities, this well-maintained property combines modern updates, versatility, and room to grow!

2101 N Main Street, Flagstaff

$890,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 204737 MLS

Exceptional redevelopment opportunity in the heart of Old Town Flagstaff. Positioned on a Highway Commercial-zoned parcel in a high-demand location near NAU, established residential neighborhoods, and key transportation corridors, this property presents a rare opportunity for developers, investors, and builders seeking future density potential in a rapidly evolving area. The primary value lies in the land, zoning flexibility, and ongoing entitlement efforts. Sellers are currently pursuing entitlement pathways that may allow for preservation of the existing residence while adding 5 townhomes, or alternatively redevelopment of the site for up to 8 townhomes (buyer to independently verify zoning, density, entitlements, permitted uses, and municipal approvals). See additional comments... Situated within the area impacted by Flagstaff's continued growth and the evolving Downtown Mile corridor, the property benefits from strong connectivity, proximity to Northern Arizona University, nearby employment centers, and increasing housing demand. The location also offers convenient access to Butler Avenue, Milton Road, and Route 66, supporting both residential and mixed-use potential. The existing 6-bedroom structure is present on site and may provide interim utility; however, the opportunity is best suited for buyers focused on redevelopment, entitlement completion, land value, and long-term investment potential. Opportunities for commercially zoned infill parcels with potential higher-density outcomes in central Flagstaff are increasingly limited, making this a compelling acquisition for those seeking a strategic development position in one of Northern Arizona's strongest markets.

823 W Clay Avenue, Flagstaff

$890,000

204589 MLS

Exceptional redevelopment opportunity in the heart of Old Town Flagstaff. Positioned on a Highway Commercial-zoned parcel in a high-demand location near NAU, established residential neighborhoods, and key transportation corridors, this property presents a rare opportunity for developers, investors, and builders seeking future density potential in a rapidly evolving area. The primary value lies in the land, zoning flexibility, and ongoing entitlement efforts. Sellers are currently pursuing entitlement pathways that may allow for preservation of the existing residence while adding 5 townhomes, or alternatively redevelopment of the site for up to 8 townhomes (buyer to independently verify zoning, density, entitlements, permitted uses, and municipal approvals). See additional comments... Situated within the area impacted by Flagstaff's continued growth and the evolving Downtown Mile corridor, the property benefits from strong connectivity, proximity to Northern Arizona University, nearby employment centers, and increasing housing demand. The location also offers convenient access to Butler Avenue, Milton Road, and Route 66, supporting both residential and mixed-use potential. The existing 6-bedroom structure is present on site and may provide interim utility; however, the opportunity is best suited for buyers focused on redevelopment, entitlement completion, land value, and long-term investment potential. Opportunities for commercially zoned infill parcels with potential higher-density outcomes in central Flagstaff are increasingly limited, making this a compelling acquisition for those seeking a strategic development position in one of Northern Arizona's strongest markets.

823 W Clay Avenue, Flagstaff

$749,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 204553 MLS

Nestled on 5.95 acres along an original stretch of Historic Route 66 at the iconic Walnut Creek Bridge, this charming farmhouse offers a rare blend of history and modern comfort. Backing directly to Walnut Creek, the property enjoys amazing views of Mount Elden and the San Francisco Peaks. Cozy and efficient 4bd, 2ba w/ den and sunroom, detached 2-car garage, and pumphouse. Updated and renovated to blend modern comfort and stylish updates w/ historic character and charm. Rare opportunity to own this unique home on a large piece of land w/ room for an ADU or horse setup. owner/agent

12851 Townsend-Winona Road, Flagstaff

$999,900

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 204445 MLS

INVESTOR SPECIAL!! Two Single Family homes on one lot! Close to NAU, shopping, restaurants and downtown Flagstaff. Larger home built in 2007, smaller home in 1948. Larger home is 3 bdrm, 2.5 baths; smaller home is 3 bdrm, 1 bath. One home could be lived in, while the other is rented out! Larger home has in-floor heating throughout and gas fireplace. Smaller home is furnace. Neither units have central AC. Both homes have been well maintained, are close to NAU, and would make excellent rental properties for students or families for years to come. Both homes have in-home washer & dryer. Unit 1 has a completed upstairs attic, but needs some adjusting to make the entry way larger/accessible. It is closed off currently. Could unlock much bigger space for more rent.

903 W Clay Avenue, Flagstaff

$1,249,900

204206 MLS

4-unit income property at 715 W Summit Ave in the Flagstaff Townsite neighborhood, Flagstaff, AZ 86001, consisting of a private detached house and a separate 3-unit apartment building on a single 10,593 SF parcel. This configuration is rare in downtown Flagstaff (grandfathered, legally established nonconforming multi-family) and gives a buyer two distinct options: acquire as a pure investment property with four income-producing units, or live in the detached house and collect rent from the three apartments to offset housing costs. The detached house, Unit A, is a 1945 single-story cottage with 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 732 square feet. The apartment building, constructed in 1985, contains three 2-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom units of approximately 875 square feet each.

715 W Summit Avenue, Flagstaff

$1,780,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 6945393 MLS

Just off the heart of historic downtown Flagstaff, the England House has stood for over a century as a symbol of craftsmanship, care, and quiet beauty. Built in 1902 by the England family, this two-story Victorian home glows with locally quarried red sandstone and the kind of character that can't be recreated today. Inside, every corner tells a story — pressed-tin ceilings, handcrafted wood details, and rooms filled with light and history. The main house offers five bedrooms and five baths, while just beyond its doors lies a private courtyard, shaded and fully enclosed, leading to a second home with two bedrooms, two baths, a loft, and modern comforts. Together, the homes form a peaceful retreat in the center of town - perfect for extended family, guests, or simply enjoying space and privacy in one of Flagstaff's most beloved neighborhoods. Furnishings may convey at buyer's discretion. Rarely does a home with such heritage, heart, and opportunity come to market. The England House isn't just a home it's a piece of Flagstaff's story, lovingly cared for and ready for its next chapter.

614 W Santa Fe Avenue, Flagstaff

$999,900

202581 MLS

INVESTOR SPECIAL!! Two Single Family homes on one lot! Close to NAU, shopping, restaurants and downtown Flagstaff. Larger home built in 2007, smaller home in 1948. Larger home is 3 bdrm, 2.5 baths; smaller home is 3 bdrm, 1 bath. One home could be lived in, while the other is rented out! Larger home has in-floor heating throughout and gas fireplace. Smaller home is furnace. Neither units have central AC. Both homes have been well maintained, are close to NAU, and would make excellent rental properties for students or families for years to come. Both homes have in-home washer & dryer. Unit 1 has a completed upstairs attic, but needs some adjusting to make the entry way larger/accessible. It is closed off currently. Could unlock much bigger space for more rent.

903 W Clay Avenue, Flagstaff

$1,780,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 202551 MLS

Just off the heart of historic downtown Flagstaff, the England House has stood for over a century as a symbol of craftsmanship, care, and quiet beauty. Built in 1902 by the England family, this two-story Victorian home glows with locally quarried red sandstone and the kind of character that can't be recreated today. Inside, every corner tells a story — pressed-tin ceilings, handcrafted wood details, and rooms filled with light and history. The main house offers five bedrooms and five baths, while just beyond its doors lies a private courtyard, shaded and fully enclosed, leading to a second home with two bedrooms, two baths, a loft, and modern comforts. Together, the homes form a peaceful retreat in the center of town - perfect for extended family, guests, or simply enjoying space and privacy in one of Flagstaff's most beloved neighborhoods. Furnishings may convey at buyer's discretion. Rarely does a home with such heritage, heart, and opportunity come to market. The England House isn't just a home it's a piece of Flagstaff's story, lovingly cared for and ready for its next chapter.

614 W Santa Fe Avenue, Flagstaff

$1,950,000

201055 MLS

Find the ultimate space for YOUR business here at 417 Santa Fe! Located in the heart of downtown Flagstaff, this 6,000 sq/ft of flexible commercial space offers a rare mix of warehouse, shop, and studio potential—all under one roof. Whether you're expanding, relocating, or launching something new, the possibilities here are wide open. High visibility and prime foot traffic during Flagstaff's vibrant spring and summer seasons make this a standout location for customer-facing businesses. Just two miles from I-40, it's also an easy stop for out-of-town visitors and travelers. Formerly home to the Daily Sun for nearly 50 years, this building is ready to make headlines again—this time with your business at the center.

417 W Santa Fe Avenue, Flagstaff

$825,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 199776 MLS

A RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN ONE OF THE FEW HISTORIC ROUTE 66 ICONS LEFT. Toonerville was built in 1933 by Earl Tinnin and his wife. The property was a residence, gas station, and trading post on historic Route 66 until 1971. It is easily assessable and visible from I-40. The main building is a 4,270 Square Foot structure that includes approximately 1300 Square Feet of retail space and a 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms residence. It also includes a large 1,861 Square feet of shop, garage, and storage building. Five Minutes from Twin Arrows Casino/Resort. What a great historic location for a RV Park! Buy now and be ready for the 100th anniversary of Historic Route 66 in 2026!

100 Twin Arrows Road, Flagstaff

605 - Shultz/Creighton Historical Properties for Sale

Newest 605 - Shultz/Creighton Historical Properties for Sale

Broaddus Properties Group

Search

Resources

About